Intelligence Squared US: Can Constitutional Free Speech Principles Save Social Media Companies from Themselves?

(Rochester, NY) – How should the world’s largest social media companies respond to a pernicious online climate, including hate speech and false content posted by users? For some, the answer is clear: take the fake and offensive content down. But for others, censorship – even by a private company – is dangerous in a time when digital platforms have become the new public square and many Americans cite Facebook and Twitter as their primary news sources. Rather than embracing European hate speech laws or developing platform-specific community standards that are sometimes seen as partisan, they argue, social media companies should voluntarily adopt the First Amendment and block content only if it violates American law. Should First Amendment doctrine govern free speech online? Or are new, more internationally focused speech policies better equipped to handle the modern challenges of regulating content and speech in the digital era? Intelligence Squared US: Can Constitutional Free Speech Principles Save Social Media Companies from Themselves? asks these questions and more, Sunday, June 9, 2019 at 9 p.m. on AM 1370. 

For the motion is David French − Senior Writer, National Review and Corynne McSherry − Legal Director, Electronic Frontier Foundation. Against the motion is Nathaniel Persily − Professor, Stanford Law and Marietje Schaake − Dutch Politician & Member, European Parliament. John Donvan hosts.

Program title card
Credit: Intelligence Squared US


WXXI is the essential, life-long educational media resource for the Greater Rochester area. WXXI puts the community first with programming that stimulates and expands thought, inspires the spirit, opens cultural horizons and promotes understanding of diverse community issues. Log on to for more information about our services and programs.


WXXI Media Contact:

Kristin Tutino

Creative Services Department



Go to the NPR Pressroom

Go to the PBS Pressroom

Get logos for Media Use

Read our Media Policy

Radio Archives

TV Archives